Chinese vs European Capitalism

Updated: Mar 4

By Dr Tan Kee Wee

This past week, both China and Europe marked the birth of its own form of capitalism. But only China celebrated it.

A few days ago (14 Oct), President Xi Jinping was in bustling Shenzhen in Guangdong Province to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the establishment of the Shenzhen Special Economic Zone (SEZ).

Between 1950 and 1980, hundreds of thousands of Chinese, facing hunger and poverty in the mainland, risked their lives by swimming across the treacherous waters to neighbouring Hong Kong. A successful crossing meant a new life. Failure meant imprisonment or death.

Deng Xiaoping, then the leader of China, realised that the solution laid not in tightening border security but in improving the Guangdong economy. And so Shenzhen, the first of many SEZs, was started in 1980.

It wasn’t enough just to give foreign investors cheap land, wages, and numerous tax breaks. Deng Xiaoping wanted to direct the Chinese people’s mindset away from a planned economy to one with a profit motive (capitalism).

The opportunity to re-educate the Chinese people arose when the national debate about the business practice of a Mr Nian Guangjiu appeared a few months later.

Nian Guangjiu (centre) selling sunflower seeds (shazi guazi) in early 1980s

Nian, an illiterate farmer from Anhui Province, started a business selling delicious sunflower seeds on the back of China’s economic reforms. He was so successful that he was soon employing more than 100 workers in his factory to keep up with demand. But there was a problem.

According to one of Karl Marx’s paragraphs in his famous book Das Kapital, there was a capitalist who exploited his 8 workers. Suddenly, Nain’s situation sparked national debate since he employed more than 7 workers. Nain had become a shameful capitalist.

Deng took the opportunity to defend Nain and removed any anxiety about running a business for profit. Deng announced that even if China allowed Nain to go on selling his seeds, it would not hurt socialism. No one questioned such business practices after Deng’s statement.

Ever since, the Chinese economy has seen a remarkable turnaround. The success of Deng’s reforms has dispelled any doubts over whether China should move from a planned economy to a market economy. But it is a market economy whereby the state continues to pull the strings. I shall label this Chinese Capitalism.

It is a form of capitalism that is quite different from the European Capitalism (my label) which has evolved. This began more than 500 years ago when Christopher Columbus, the Italian explorer, discovered the New World on 12 October 1492.

Christopher Columbus (kneeling) arrives in the New World on 12 Oct 1492

Before Columbus sailed off with his three ships, he had great difficulty raising money for the voyage. After many failed attempts, he finally found the Catholic Monarchs of Spain as a sponsor. But there was a catch. It was to be an investment project. So, Columbus sailed off as an entrepreneur with a profit motive.

When his voyages earned him the riches that he sought, news of his voyages spread throughout Europe. People realised that they too could make money from tobacco and sugar plantations, and from gold and silver mines. Suddenly, more money became available. Like the internet start-ups of today, many entrepreneurs came forth.

Columbus’ discovery of the New World was supremely important because it started a long period of European exploration, conquest and colonisation that helped to create the modern Western world.

It’s interesting to note that Columbus wasn’t the first person to sail to distant lands. That title easily falls on Admiral Zheng He of the Ming Dynasty (1368-1644 AD). Between 1405 and 1433 AD, Zheng He was commissioned by the Ming emperor to conduct 7 voyages, using some 300 ships, to distant parts of the world.

Admiral Zheng He and his fleet of 300 ships.  Source: Caravan Daily

Unlike Columbus, the profit motive did not dominate Zheng He’s seven voyages. Among his objectives were – to capture the emperor’s predecessor, establish Chinese presence, impose control on the sea trade routes, and extend the emperor’s tributary system.

So, when the enemies of the Ming Dynasty reappeared in northern China towards the end of the seven voyages, these non-profitable and expensive sea voyages had to be axed.

Some people have said that the non-exploitative and non-colonising voyages of Zheng He proved that China did not, and going forward, would not want to colonise the world as a 21st century superpower. This may be true. But it is also true that the profit motive was not part of Zheng He’s seven voyages.

Let’s go back to European Capitalism. The fuel beneath this capitalism following the discovery of the New World was profit. It spurred innovative vehicles like the stock market, where the public could put in a small sum of money in a listed company, knowing that the listed company would do its utmost to deliver the profits.

Throughout Europe, scores of companies were created and listed to organise the spice trade, the commodities trade and the slave trade.

Nowadays, we look back and view the slave trade with disdain. But in those days, many shareholders were not worried about the cruelty inflicted on slaves.

It’s the same today. Many shareholders of meat or dairy companies are not concerned about the cruelty inflicted on the anima